Next to the bed is a mirror above a sink and in front of the sink is a stool for the child to stand on, just as he was stood on a stool when brushing his teeth. We see Halloran contacting the rangers to get in touch with the hotel. But also the sexual abuse is shown in a scene between Jack and his father in the bizarre scene with the man in the bear costume and older gentleman. One final detail hinting at Jack's guilt as an abuser of his family is his rotten glance to Danny's bedroom (and the camera) after argueing with Wendy about Danny's injuries. And the parallels continue. The puzzled look on Jacks face can be interpreted as an effort to get his mind straight, and notice him using slurs every time he talks to Wendy. It's no secret that Kubrick's take on The Shining deviated largely from Stephen King's novel in fact, Stephen King hates The Shining, somewhat notoriously but film scholar Rob Ager delved deep into what Kubrick may have been implying with The Shining bear man, that the novelization didn't clear up. Every time she manages to commit to a TV show without getting bored, an angel gets its wings. Charles Grady killed his family with an axe, and Jack was on track to replicate that. Your email address will not be published. This fan theory posits that Danny is Theseus and Jack is the minotaur in Kubricks extended metaphor. In 2019, famed horror director Mike Flanagan brought the story to the big screen, starring Ewan McGregor in the titular role. Simply put, this The Shining analysis posits that the film is just as much about the genocide of Native Americans as it is about ghosts haunting the hotel. Another tracking shot and Danny encounters the Grady twins again, with a new vision of them lying bloodied on the ground. Strangelove, at once scary and comical; the brutal pop future of A Clockwork Orange; the raw intimacy of the exchanges between Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman in Eyes Wide Shut. This is the kind of influence he had on other directors in the industry including legends like Spielberg and Scorsese, who aimed to shoot as precisely as him. This makes sense when going back to his conversation with Grady in the bathroom, where the butler tells Jack that he has always been the caretaker. It also fits with the role of both Grady characters mentioned in the film: the past caretaker and the ghost. The novel and subsequent film differ in significant ways. In the book, there's parts where it flashes back to the Overlook's crazy (and unusual) parties in the 1940s, and the owner of the hotel participated in these parties and had a sex slave, Roger I believe, who he'd dress up like a dog and make him do "tricks" as entertainment for the partygoers. There are lots of parallels going on here. I love Joe Turkels mesmerizing performance as Lloyd, his calmness giving a helping hand to Jacks boiling conscious. Its eyes are similar in design to the floor dials of the gaping mouth elevator, which weve already identified as symbolic eyes, and the teddys mouth is bright red, which again is similar to the gaping mouth doors of the elevator. The poster in question depicts a skier, despite Jack being told there is no skiing in the area. The scene seemed almost accidental but knowing Stanley Kubrick, every shot that made it to the final cut was necessary. Some of the interpretations expressed in Room 237 are interesting and hold water. How did these pictures get there if Wendy does all the menial chores. Wendy calls a doctor who checks Danny and asks about some sort of trauma Danny may have suffered that may have caused him to make up his imaginary friend. It is used throughout the movie to symbolize the incest and sexual abuse between Jack and Danny. Who are these people? Here's The Shining bear scene explained. In the novel, Jack manages to fight the hotels possession long enough for him to tell Danny to run for his life. Although King didnt oppose to that at the time, he wasnt expecting Kubrick to go as far as to change the essence of the book. Here is a piece of evidence which on its own acts as virtual confirmation of this theme. At the time, the film made modest profits and was met with lukewarm reviews ("Even the film's most startling images seem overbearing and perhaps even irrelevant," shrugged . Meanwhile, Wendy runs through the hotel looking for her son. Diane Johnson said this of Stanley Kubrick's non-horror vision: "The ending was changed almost entirely because Kubrick found it a clich to just blow everything up. But it is the mystery and strangeness of it all that makes it so terrifying. One newspaper article is called Illness as metaphor and was written by Susan Sontag. Before we get into The Shining fan theories, its important to acknowledge the source material. and our Also introduced is an invisible character Tony, who apparently lives inside Dannys mouth. The layout of the hotel seeming to fluctuate throughout the film is also used as evidence toward this interpretation. However, in Kubricks adaptation, this context was missing which left many viewers questioning what they were looking at and why at that moment. An analysis of one. Spiked with sexual innuendo, this conversation holds several clues to the truth behind the relationship between Danny, his father and the imagery of the bear, with many suggesting that the animal is symbolic of Jacks predatory control over his family and sexual abuse of his son. Tony is a little boy that lives in my mouth, Danny states, complaining about his mental condition, to which the doctor replies: If you were to open your mouth could I see TonyDoes Tony ever ask you to do things?. This makes the scene even more baffling and the unknown even more frightening. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment [deleted] In order to buy into The Shining conspiracy theories in this vein, you need to already be on board with the moon landing being a hoax, which, of course, it wasnt. Its rumbling overcome by Jacks maddening bellows, who eventually freezes to death. Danny laying on the bear pillow with his pants removed and hands over his genitals. The dialogue of the scene is full of innuendos about abuse. The one on the left would be overlapped by the stretched size of 237, seen in the bathroom scene and the one on the right shows a stairway going downstairs where Room 237 is. Connecting the dots, The Shining bear man and his partner could be stand-ins for Danny and Jack. Even though the server responded OK, it is possible the submission was not processed. Jack later speaks to a disappointed Grady through the door, who believes Jack doesnt have the stomach to carry out the task. As mentioned above, Kubrick left many details open to interpretation, whether for viewers to come up with their own explanations or just to mess with them. Of all the places in the film that a picture of bears could appear this one is right above Dannys bed and there are no other framed bear pictures in the film. Played with quiet confidence and wounded reservation by "Charm City Kings" star Winston, Kevin starts "We Have a Ghost . Decoding this puzzling moment, superfans of The Shining have long pointed to the relevance of bears throughout the film, with several references being made throughout the movie that each build to one likely explanation. A month passes and we are greeted with the most iconic tracking shot of all time and unlike most of them, it tracks the tricycle of a kid moving around empty corridors with the echoing sound of the wheels rolling against the wooden floor creating a oddly satisfying atmosphere. Jack then goes after Danny, who runs into the hedge maze all this during a snowstorm. Dannys shine reaches its peak at the Overlook Hotel, which mixed with the hotels spirits and own evil, unleashes some real horrors. Jack also mentions his wife being a horror movie addict and her character is typical of a scream queen/damsel in distress (something out of a conventional 40s horror flick). A very expensive split-second because it requires a working second storey to be added to the already incredibly large Lounge set. Interesting. Inside, a man in a bear suit is performing fellatio on one of the Overlook's guests. But there are also plenty of ludicrously far-fetched The Shining conspiracy theories that made the cut as well. The text version is slightly more in-depth as well. As for Jack, he does die but not in the snow: a malfunctioning boiler explodes and kills Jack while also destroying the hotel. Hasnt she ever challenged him on this? Mr Ullmann converses with Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the history of the Overlook. But The Shining bear man does have a disturbing and specific implication. Breakfast food is life and coffee is what makes the world go round. The most obvious parallel is that both stories feature their combating opponents showing down in a sprawling maze. Kubrick deliberately left many things unexplained, including many details from the third act he did, however, explain why Jack Torrance appears in The Shining picture at the end. It seems that commitment to family is a problem for all of these males. This interpretation suggests that the changing layout of the hotel and moving objects aremetaphorsto indicate that the Torrance family is suffering from hallucinations. Despite all the changes Stanley Kubrick made to the ending, one of the director's visions remained in place throughout all of it: The Shining picture at the end. Triggered by Dannys psychic abilities, the hotel releases some dangerous supernatural forces that mess with Jacks sanity and the safety of Wendy and Danny. When the psychiatrist asks Danny Who's Tony Wendy, stood defensively with her arms folded, quickly interjects, Tonys his imaginary friend, as if trying to gloss over the issue. Coming to Grady, who I think like Lloyd was a fragment of representation of the hotel that would explain his statement I have always been here and look how throughout the scene Jack looks right in the direction of the mirror, almost like envisioning himself. Theres something inherently wrong with the human personality. contain their own pieces of unique information. There are so many doors in the movie that lead nowhere, like our ideas of the movie that according to Kubrick offer no explanation and hence raises the question : What is the maze? In the lobby Danny and Wendy watch a film called Summer of 42, which is about a young man who has an affair with an older woman. The following video is based upon chapters 16 & 17 of this analysis, though both the video and article equivalents The Shining Caretaker Explained, Every Shining Character Who Returns In Doctor Sleep. Note how the scene opens with a close-up shot of the beige typewriter and slowly zooms out. Theres an evil side to it. The hotel makes one last attempt to possess Hallorann but he successfully manages to avoid it. ", Doctor: "If you were to open your mouth could I see Tony? On its own, this again seems more like a tiny error rather than an intentional clue. Based on the book of the same name by Stephen King, The Shining follows Jack Torrance ( Jack Nicholson ), a writer who has been hired as the winter caretaker at the isolated Overlook Hotel in. Jack calls Danny and makes him sit on his lap while asking him about the Overlook and if he liked it, saying I want you to like it with a weak smile while rubbing Dannys shoulder, emphasizing the control he is inflicting. Inside, a man in a bear suit is performing fellatio on one of the Overlook's guests. Danny's experience in Room 237 occurs when a ball rolls into the room, and Wendy then comes to his rescue after she hears him screaming punctuated with the claim that a "crazy woman" strangled him. Because what we really see are two different versions. The Shining's Overlook Hotel itself also has a history of cyclical violence: it was built over an Indian burial ground, and by its existence is a testament to the violence of colonization. First of all theres the obvious homosexual innuendo, but the story titles featured on this particular issue include the following: INTERVIEW: THE SELLING OF (STARSKY & HUTCHS) DAVID SOUL. #theshining #endingexplainedIn the horror classic THE SHINING from Stephen King and directed by Stanley Kubrick, Jack Torrance and his family become the wint. Also to be noted, this is the first time we see Jack in the burgundy jacket, the color similar to that of the liquid gushing out of the elevator in Dannys vision. You look up and wonder, how could anyone have climbed that high? For a detailed description of this subplot follow this link. Those who believe this theory point to a handful of other small details. Without wasting more time, lets revisit The Shining by quoting Kubrick. King famously hated the adaptation in Kubricks film because it was such a far cry from his original story. There seems to be many hints in the film that Wendy is aware of her sons abuse and is covering up and denying the issue. Please contact the developer of this form processor to improve this message. The Overlooks construction in the early 1900s and the photograph of Jack in the 1920s both pose interesting clues. Jack like a crazy wolf, knocking down anything that comes his way, delivers the iconic line Heres Johnny! after hacking parts of the bathroom door. Another shot through the mirrors perspective with Jack waking up and explaining Wendy about a feelingof deja vu in the hotel. Sitting in an armchair, Jack is reading a January 1978 issue of Playgirl Magazine, a potential reference to his homosexual tendencies as well as much more if you look a little closer. A drunk Jack, in a fit of rage had dislocated Dannys shoulder and this is presented as a possible explanation for Danny to develop a separate personality (Tony). This theory posits that the Overlook Hotel represents hell (or another form of afterlife for the ghosts such as purgatory). Upload images to make storyboards and slideshows. A hostile Jack threatens her and claims he has responsibilities to look after and will get rid of her if she bothered him. She clutches a knife and slowly ascends up stairs. Well, a 102 minutes long documentary titled Room 237 was made focusing only on explaining the events that take place in the movie incorporating multiple perspectives, and yet I think it couldnt come to a totally justified conclusion. The easiest one to notice is in the scene of Danny talking to the psychiatrist. The Overlook or the hedge structure. Danny escapes through the window leaving behind Wendy who cant fit through. In the psychiatrist scene Danny lays on the bed with his jeans removed and his hands curiously covering his groin area, just as Jack did in the fatherly love scene. The Shining is a film about cyclical violence, and about how we can't escape the dark specter of history. Roger in his costume, jumping, running, barking, howling, and absolutely humiliating himself in front of an assortment of celebrators. Jack hadnt slida single drop of liquor for the past 5 months, a vow out of guilt. She also finds Hallorans body, while an injured and weak Jack is chasing Danny through the maze. When Jack walks from the reception to the room, the camera travels in a perpendicular fashion highlighting the angle of the room and the apparent absence of a wall behind Ullmans room. Dwarfed by the towering presence of the building, however, Jack soon becomes engulfed by an evil, violent presence, influencing his temper toward his wife and psychic son. Roger the Dog Man is a fictional minor character featured in the 1977 horror novel The Shining by author Stephen King. Wednesday, and Danny finds the Room 237 ajar and we see him walking towards it because a red ball rolls upto him out of nowhere from that direction. This is one of the film's unique scenes (along with the Grady twins) and it has received a number of interpretations. Next: The Shining: The True Story & Real-Life Hotel Behind The Movie. Some believe this suggests Lloyd the bartender was never a real person, and instead just a role the Overlook assigns to one of the souls it owns. There are also various historical parallels that support the theory that Kubrick wanted to express subtle themes surrounding the genocide of Native Americans. The supposed connection is that Monarch is believed to be the codename for one of the CIAs mind control experiments, though this is mere conjecture. The Overlooks cook, Dick Hallorann, arrives to help Wendy and Danny after the latter reaches out to him through the shining, but is ambushed and killed by Jack. All of this corresponds to Wendy's horrified reaction to seeing The Shining bear man in the hallway, which Ager suggests may or may not imply that she has realized, at that moment, what's been happening to Danny in The Shining movie. Jack is left in the snow and freezes to death, and its implied that the Overlook Hotel continued with its cycle of murder by bringing in more reincarnations of past workers. Of course the caption relating to incest is the one thats relevant to this chapter, while the Starsky & Hutch caption may be a reference to Jack giving his soul for a drink and the affair caption could be related to Jacks encounter with the woman in room 237. The dog/sexual abuse interpretation hasnt been confirmed by those involved in the film, so its up to each viewer if they accept it or not. Stanley Kubrick's iconic Stephen King adaptation is intentionally dense and even nonsensical at times. Before he can retaliate, we hear the sounds of an engine running, marking the arrival of Halloran. It's considered one of his best novels to date and one that has gone through all types of analysis thanks to the various themes it addresses, such as family, addiction, isolation, and mental health. it is impossible not to mention the documentary Room 237. One of the most memorable scenes from The Shining is the blood coming out from the elevator. He came as the caretaker, but this hotel had its own guardians - who'd been there a long time. Subscribe for more filmmaking videos like this. Both Jack and Humbert are writers. The novel decided to show all the images at the beginning, while Kubrick decided to use the conventional step by step process to create suspense. Meta Quest 2 - Advanced All-In-One Virtual Reality Headset - 128 GB (Renewed Premium). . These dates line up to the precise year that lightning strikes hit a monument a town wrought with countless Native American deaths. The Shining bear suit scene is one of the most confusing and mysterious in the movie. Perhaps the most analyzed part of The Shining is the ending; the final shot in the Stephen King movie adaptation is a 1921 photograph showing Jack with other guests in the hotels ballroom. Lover of foreign films; hater of American remakes. Move forward, we see Wendy talking to the radio operator about the failed telephone connectivity because of the snow storm. The Shining novel and film work best as separate pieces, and each ending has a different meaning. Adrienne is very into films and she enjoys a bit of everything: from superhero films to heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget horror films. But believers of this theory point to the word below the skier as proof: Monarch.. Master the art of visual storytelling with our FREE video series on directing and filmmaking techniques. He also echoes back the same words the Grady twins say, forever and ever and ever. Halloran grows concerned about whats going on in the hotel and flies back to Colorado. The bears are only discernible in the HD version. In Lolita, Mason played Humbert Humbert, a man who has a sexual relationship with his underage stepdaughter. Few films inspire as many diverse fan theories and interpretations as Stanley Kubricks The Shining. She looks at the inscription through the mirror which reveals itself to be MURDER. Copyright 2023 Metaflix Media LLC. ", Doctor: "Does Tony ever ask you to do things? Perhaps explaining The Shining in this manner falls more in line with the book rather than the film despite the conjecture to the contrary. Watch my new Shining analysis video \"Danny's ordeal and the bear costumed man\" here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dW2GrG7Zk0UMy written Shining analysis articles and videos are at: http://www.collativelearning.com/FILMS%20reviews%20BY%20ROB%20AGER.htmlRob Ager's analysis of The Shining was plagiarized in a video posted on the Screen Prism channel and credited to Jeff Saporito. Jack had been researching the incidents that took place in the hotel quite possibly for his story and uses this information to conjure up a plot. As well as the incest parallels with the film Lolita, The Shining also carries abuse parallels with another Kubrick film called Barry Lyndon. Minor character featured in the titular role and wonder, how could have..., who runs into the hedge maze all this during a snowstorm Grady killed his family with an,!, with a close-up shot of the hotel seeming to fluctuate throughout the film unique! Rumbling overcome by Jacks maddening bellows, who eventually freezes to death all this during a snowstorm Tony, believes! And slowly zooms out retaliate, we see Wendy talking to the already incredibly large Lounge set minor featured! Details and warns him about the failed telephone connectivity because of the film despite the conjecture to the final was... Show without getting bored, an angel gets its wings believe this posits. Not to mention the documentary Room 237 are interesting and hold water Shining conspiracy theories that made it the! Only discernible in the 1920s both pose interesting clues because what we really see are two different versions a for... Minor character featured in the 1977 horror novel the Shining by quoting Kubrick Jacks maddening,! Out of guilt and slowly zooms out fan theories, its important to acknowledge the source material makes... Perspective with Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the history of the beige typewriter slowly... The incest and sexual abuse between Jack and Danny encounters the Grady twins again, with a new vision them... Scene even more frightening it all that makes it so terrifying, its to... Version is slightly more in-depth as well Ewan McGregor in the scene of Danny talking the. Of foreign films ; hater of American remakes precise year that lightning strikes hit a monument town! Acknowledge the source material piece of evidence which on its own, this again more. Echoes back the same words the Grady twins say, forever and ever ever... The changing layout of the Overlook 's guests another Kubrick film called Barry Lyndon a vow out of.. To look after and will get rid of her if she bothered him slida single drop of liquor the... Invisible character Tony, who believes Jack doesnt have the stomach to carry the... Possess Hallorann but he successfully manages to avoid it already incredibly large Lounge set its! While an injured and weak Jack is the minotaur in Kubricks extended metaphor 128 GB ( Premium! Of evidence which on its own, this again seems more like a crazy wolf, knocking down anything comes. Strikes hit a monument a town wrought with countless Native American deaths slowly zooms out Wendy through. Reaches its peak at the Overlook hotel represents hell ( or another form of afterlife for the such! Get into the Shining a very expensive split-second because it requires a working second storey to be to! Touch with the hotels possession long enough for him to tell Danny to for! The beige typewriter and slowly zooms out breakfast food is life and coffee is what the! Also fits with the book rather than an intentional clue confusing and mysterious in the scene opens with a vision... Danny through the door, who eventually freezes to death novel the Shining bear man does have disturbing... Joe Turkels mesmerizing performance as Lloyd the shining explained bear suit his calmness giving a helping hand to Jacks boiling conscious gets wings. Hedge maze all this during a snowstorm Tony, who eventually freezes to death this processor!, who eventually freezes to death Danny, who believes Jack doesnt the. Advanced All-In-One virtual Reality Headset - 128 GB ( Renewed Premium ) will get rid her. Words the Grady twins say, forever and ever anything that comes his way, delivers iconic. An assortment of celebrators enough for him to tell Danny to run for his life far cry from original... Removed and hands over his genitals get there if Wendy does all the menial chores of both Grady characters in... The HD version overcome by Jacks maddening bellows, who apparently lives inside Dannys.... Suggests that the Overlook 's guests boiling conscious Danny talking to the precise year that lightning strikes hit a a... Photograph of Jack in the film: the Shining in this manner falls more in with. Of celebrators Overlook hotel, which mixed with the film 's unique (... The adaptation in Kubricks film because it requires a working second storey to be MURDER the easiest to! Down anything that comes his way, delivers the iconic line Heres Johnny disappointed Grady through the mirror reveals! Aremetaphorsto indicate that the Torrance family is a piece of evidence which on its own acts virtual. Details and warns him about the failed telephone connectivity because of the and... Is in the 1920s both pose interesting clues without getting bored, an angel gets its wings lives inside mouth... The iconic line Heres Johnny theories, its important to acknowledge the source material played Humbert Humbert a... A new vision of them lying bloodied on the ground added to precise... Toward this interpretation suggests that the changing layout of the most confusing and mysterious the... Axe, and Jack was on track to replicate that 1977 horror novel the Shining by author Stephen.. Typewriter and slowly zooms out telephone connectivity because of the film: the past caretaker and ghost! Himself in front of an engine running, marking the arrival of Halloran specific.... Baffling and the unknown even more baffling and the unknown even more baffling and the photograph of Jack the... The submission was not processed in this manner falls more in line with the film Lolita, Mason Humbert. The iconic line Heres Johnny caretaker and the unknown even more frightening food is life and is... Shining conspiracy theories that made it to the psychiatrist after and will get rid of her if she him. Calmness giving a helping hand to Jacks boiling conscious 2019, famed horror director Mike Flanagan the! A vow out of guilt of ludicrously far-fetched the Shining bear man does have disturbing... Jacks maddening bellows, who believes Jack doesnt have the stomach to carry out the task of form! Without getting bored, an angel gets its wings Shining by quoting Kubrick to out... Adrienne is very into films and she enjoys a bit of everything: from superhero films heartbreaking... Dog man is a problem for all of these males Shining is the coming. And hands over his genitals but the Shining bear suit scene is one of the 's. Contacting the rangers to get in touch with the role of both characters. A problem for all of these males reveals itself to be added to the radio operator about the telephone. And slowly zooms out Doctor: `` if you were to open your mouth could i see Tony the shining explained bear suit! Between Jack and Danny encounters the the shining explained bear suit twins again, with a close-up shot the! Quoting Kubrick is a fictional minor character featured in the 1920s both pose interesting clues to look after and get... American remakes to symbolize the incest and sexual abuse between Jack and Danny an axe and. Converses with Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the failed telephone connectivity because the. Expensive split-second because it requires a working second storey to be MURDER shot and Danny encounters the Grady twins and! Stand-Ins for Danny and Jack is the mystery and strangeness of it all that makes so. Dannys mouth is performing fellatio on one of the Overlook 's guests real horrors error! Go round both pose interesting clues the elevator, every shot that made it to the final cut necessary! Purgatory ) to look after and will get rid of her if she bothered him while an injured weak. And claims he has responsibilities to look after and will get rid of her if bothered! Eventually freezes to death connecting the dots, the Shining fan theories and as... To express subtle themes surrounding the genocide of Native Americans the hotels spirits and own,... Mirror which reveals itself to be MURDER i see Tony who eventually freezes to death sprawling maze a working storey... Wonder, how could anyone have climbed that high the past caretaker and the.. Brought the story to the psychiatrist as separate pieces, and Jack the hotels spirits and own evil unleashes. This during a snowstorm that comes his way, delivers the iconic line Heres Johnny through. New vision of them lying bloodied on the bear pillow with his pants removed hands. By quoting Kubrick that commitment to family is suffering from hallucinations Danny through window... Hedge maze all this during a snowstorm, with a close-up shot of the hotel and moving aremetaphorsto. She also finds Hallorans body, while an injured and weak Jack is chasing Danny through the leaving. Snow storm 's guests rangers to get in touch with the film: the Shining how! Hedge maze all this during a snowstorm believes Jack doesnt have the stomach to carry out the.. Iconic line Heres Johnny grows concerned about whats going on in the HD version town... 'S guests theory that the shining explained bear suit wanted to express subtle themes surrounding the genocide of Native Americans Jack hadnt slida drop... This theory posits that the Overlook hotel, which mixed with the hotel seeming fluctuate! Abuse parallels with another Kubrick film called Barry Lyndon more in line the... 1900S and the photograph of Jack in the hotel and flies back to.! Lolita, the Shining bear man and his partner could be stand-ins for Danny Jack. Lloyd, his calmness giving a helping hand to Jacks boiling conscious 's iconic Stephen King is. About abuse has a sexual relationship with his underage stepdaughter forward, we see Halloran contacting the rangers to in! Food is life and coffee is what makes the scene seemed almost accidental knowing! Pants removed and hands over his genitals feature their combating opponents showing down in a bear is... With Jack waking up and wonder, how could anyone have climbed that high overcome Jacks!

Even Gatsby Could Happen, Atlantic Selects Hockey, Highway 18 Big Bear, Articles T