Industries as varied as aviation, construction, public health, international development, energy, finance, and insurance all have shifted to utilize ERM. It is a top-down strategy that aims to identify, assess, and prepare for potential losses, dangers, hazards, and other potentials for harm that may interfere with an organization's operations and objectives and/or lead to losses. This means that it is either reacting to an event that has taken place in the present or preventing an event that has taken place in the past. Its the expression of your companys risk culture, your risk tolerance, your appetite for risk. Review and Monitor the Risk: The last step is to continuously monitor and reviewing the risks so that it doesn't become bigger. This aspect is known as the probable impact. It also enables better management of market, competitive, and economic conditions, and increases leverage and consolidation of disparate risk management functions. As opposed to risks being siloed across a company, a company sees the bigger picture when using ERM. This is especially true because of the significant losses experienced in investments that were considered safe such as money-market funds and ultra-short bonds and in investments that supposedly had risk under control. Business risk threatens a company's ability to survive, and these risks may be further classified into different risks discussed below. In old times, companies were very orthodox in handling their businesses by handling risk exposures in all units by managing their own unit themselves. The enterprise risk management (ERM) framework is more holistic in nature. While it is often referred to in the same breath as governance, risk and compliance (GRC), the two differ, with ERM more accurately viewed as a subset of GRC. Advantages Better decision making timely delivery of projects staying ahead and This leads to less unexpected risks and more guided direction on how to respond to certain events. A committee of five organizations dedicated to thought leadership around risk management provided a definition of ERM in 2004. These include white papers, government data, original reporting, and interviews with industry experts. Of cause, many other negative effects brought by financial risk can be minimized. TheCommittee of Sponsoring Organizations (COSO)defined it as: In simple terms, ERM is a way to effectively manage risk across the organization through the use of a common risk management framework. If you need help, its easier to ask for help with elements of a recognized standard than it is your own bespoke methodology. Deliver project consistency and visibility at scale. Preventative control activities are in place to stop an activity from happening. Planning due to Risk: After evaluating the risk, management plans to take needful steps to overcome those risks. By communicating with employees, there is more likely to be greater buy-in for processes and protection over company assets. Running a business comes with many types of risk. Confirm if any of the risks has occurred. Bond rating agencies, financial statement auditors, and regulatory examiners, have begun to inquire about, test, and use monitoring and reporting data from ERM programs. Everyone will have a different perspective of what might not be working or what could be done better. Traditional risk management relies on empirical data. 3. The crux of the framework is that the enterprise risk management (ERM) model must ensure that risk management is completely aligned with the overall business model. What is the speed at which the risk will impact the various functions of the organization? Offers a greater confidence that you can achieve your strategic aims. It aware all the units in the business about the risks. WebTo identifying, prioritizing, and deal with the risks will help the company minimize unforeseen incidents and penalties and keep the business running smoothly. The Smartsheet platform makes it easy to plan, capture, manage, and report on work from anywhere, helping your team be more effective and get more done. ERM typically embraces three fundamental components: operations, financial and strategic risk management. Youre aware of all the possible curveballs and can take steps to mitigate them. WebA type of software known as enterprise resource planning (ERP) is used by organizations to handle routine business operations like accounting, purchasing, project management, Instead, it is a more creative function that uses creativity as well as statistical skills in order to predict the possible risks. These systems automate It saves the time and costs of the company with ERM. Move faster, scale quickly, and improve efficiency. This may be nearly impossible to accurately predict. In that way, the company can have back up funds in case they lose an asset. All Rights Reserved Smartsheet Inc. Since ERM data involves identifying and monitoring controls and mitigation efforts across the organization, this information can help reduce the effort and cost of such audits and reviews. Subscribe to our communications to get business tips delivered straight to your Inbox. Though the company will benefit from protecting its assets, a company must detract time of its staff and may make capital investments to implement ERM strategies. WebSingle Dimension vs. Risk management helps organizations make informed decisions to mitigate risks, as well as create informed action plans to capitalize on a business opportunity, or have a plan in case of an emergency such as a facility fire, loss of key personnel, or a critical technological failure. Keep that in mind, and look for avenues to share information, best practices, and lessons learned. 703.910.2600. ERM makes it easier for you to present your risk profile to your board and leadership team. Report: Empowering Employees to Drive Innovation, Pros and Cons of Project Risk Management Presentation Template, Streamline Your Risk Management Efforts in Real Time with Smartsheet, Improved avoidance and mitigation of risks, Better identification of troubled initiatives, Helps to establish best practices for identifying and responding to risks, Increased costs related to implementation and ongoing processes, Allows for you to make more accurate project projections, Adding complexity to processes leads to more possible points of failure, Creates processes that can be built upon and shared, Increased executive support for initiatives. It acts as a guide in decision-making and planning in the event of an emergency or an opportunity. And as always, we welcome any comments or feedback you have on this site. To begin with, financial risk management reduces the probability of financial failure of firms. In other words, ERM helps you think about how to use risk as an opportunity. WebThis objective often aligns with the strategic need for visibility and management across large-scale enterprise security topologies. Reduce incidents in the workplace. What internal and external events could impede or derail each of them? Both enterprise risk management and business risk management sit under the overarching umbrella term of risk management. Adam Hayes, Ph.D., CFA, is a financial writer with 15+ years Wall Street experience as a derivatives trader. There are numerous benefits of enterprise risk management. They are often sold as standalone software solutions or as solutions that can be integrated with the Some of these potential hazards can destroy a business or cause serious damage that is costly and time-consuming to repair.Other risks may represent opportunities. Your operations are more efficient and effective. This approach is limited: rules-based business risk management alone cannot diminish either the likelihood or the impact of a disaster and can also lessen your ability to seize business opportunities that may involve some degree of risk.. The CRO's mandate will be specified in conjunction with other top management along with the board of directors and other stakeholders. Traditional risk management is only focused on one aspect of risks. WebAdvantages and disadvantages of Enterprise Risk Management The following are some advantages of enterprise risk management: ERM assists in identifying the risks. ERM practices are often synthesized by a standardized risk report delivered to upper managem Web Regularly track risk plan and keep it current. You can proactively identify and act on risks across your organization. As a result, a company may be more efficient with its time, especially considering what is delivered to upper management. Whether delivering actionable, real-time insight to teams on the ground or giving the board a 30,000-foot view of risk ERM dramatically improves your ability to respond to the organizational threats you face. 2003-2023 Chegg Inc. All rights reserved. Evaluating risk holistically, and in the context of all internal and external environments, systems, circumstances and stakeholders, brings efficiency and effectiveness to operations in a way that isolated risk management programs cannot. However, the accident also causes a loss to the reputation of the organization. Weve also included a side-by-side comparison slide to summarize the advantages and disadvantages that risk management can bring to your business. 2023. Communicate risk and risk treatment widely and effectively. This generally means that every department discovers its own risks and makes a plan to mitigate them. Read our article for tips to improve your cash flow. The 3 Pillars of Corporate Sustainability, Capital Budgeting: What It Is and How It Works, Financial Risk: The Major Kinds That Companies Face, The Importance of Health Care Risk Management. WebCURAs Enterprise Risk Management solution streamlines risk management processes and reduces errors versus tedious and manual methods. The purpose of risk management is to pinpoint potential problems before they can affect and occur, so that the organization can planned and invoked ahead of time if needed. Weve outlined the major advantages of adopting risk management processes below: In addition to concrete business advantages, adopting project risk management processes can bring numerous, less tangible benefits to your organization, such as better communication, improved team engagement, and increased project visibility. What Types of Risks Does Enterprise Risk Management Address? I realize this list could ultimately cover several pages risk management is a very challenging aspect of business. A company's internal environment is the atmosphere and corporate culture within the company set by its employees. Analysis from the security researchers of Forrester. The enterprise risk management (ERM) framework is more holistic in nature. She has nearly two decades of experience in the financial industry and as a financial instructor for industry professionals and individuals. As I close out my client inquiry records for the quarter, its interesting to review some of the common challenges risk management professionals are currently facing. Streamline requests, process ticketing, and more. There was no CEO or other top management involvement in daily operations related to those divisions. Q.1 What are the advantages and disadvantages of environmental risk management? Many risks are in fact insurable: fire, product liability, or embezzlement among them. CLA (CliftonLarsonAllen LLP), an independent legal entity, is a network member of CLA Global, an international organization of independent accounting and advisory firms. 6. Hence, they cannot be understood while looking in a rearview mirror. ERM can help devise plans for almost any type of business risk. Work smarter and more efficiently by sharing information across platforms. These are important elements with which to create an appropriate enterprise risk management framework. If you have questions regarding individual license information, please contact Elizabeth Spencer. This harm is not easy to quantify and hence cannot be insured. helps leadership understand the most important risk areas. In addition, a company may find it difficult to quantify the success of ERM as financial risks that do not occur must simply be projected. He currently researches and teaches economic sociology and the social studies of finance at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. Project risk management offers many distinct advantages to an organization, including more accurate project projections, increased return on investments (ROI), and greater executive support and trust. WebAdvantages of risk management. All rights reserved. This may include reviewing what is actually performed compared to what policy documents suggest. Traditional risk management is often reactive in nature. Because it encompasses all areas of organizational exposure to risk, including financial, operational, reporting and compliance, one benefit of enterprise risk That shortcoming is the fact that at this point, there is no universal approach to identifying risk that must be controlled or mitigated versus those risks that are acceptable without counter-measures. One such example of an enterprise risk management strategy is to hire expert risk analysts. Try Smartsheet for free, today. These reports can also help leaders develop a better understanding of risk appetite, risk thresholds, and risk tolerances. Streamline operations and scale with confidence. This is why a more customized approach is necessary for enterprise risk management (ERM). In addition, this may lead to greater employee satisfaction knowing plans are in place to protect company resources as well as greater customer service knowing how to respond to customers should certain risks actually occur. Join Lisa Edwards, Diligent President and COO, and Fortune Media CEO Alan Murray to discuss how corporations' role in the world has shifted - and how leaders can balance the risks and opportunities of this new paradigm. Focusses oversight on most threatening risks. Meidell, A. and Kaarbe, K., 2017. Collaborative Work Management Tools, Q4 2022, Strategic Portfolio Management Tools, Q4 2020. The feeling of Responsibility to Employee 5. Organizations in all types of industries, public and private, have observed a variety of benefits from enhancing their risk management programs. Its easier to benchmark your performance against other organizations using the same approach. Find a partner or join our award-winning program. Transparency in coverage machine-readable files. Successful ERM strategies can mitigate operational, financial, security, compliance, legal, and many other types of risks. 2. One must be capable of facing the risks and the strengths to overcome it. More modern risk management has introduced ERM, a comprehensive, company-wide approach to view risk holistically for the entire company. ERM, therefore, can work to minimize firmwide risk as well as identify unique firmwide opportunities. These high risk events may pose risks to operations (i.e. What is business risk management and why is it important? This aspect is known as the probable impact. By Forrester Research, You do not have a guaranteed income as an entrepreneur. Everyone in the extended community will already know what you are talking about! The probable impact is This provides the data needed for improved decision making capabilities within the executive and director levels, and in other layers of management. One the one hand, they can improve your ability to identify and avoid risks early; on the other, they require everyone to adhere to strict procedures and might cost money to implement. As you might imagine, enterprise risk management is an organization-wide approach to managing risk. A company can turn to an internal committee or an external auditor to review its policies and practices. This framework can vary widely among organizations but typically involves people, rules, and tools. Copyright 2022 All rights are reserved. WBS Guidelines for Government Acquisition Programs (MIL-STD 881D), Knowledge Transfer, Mentoring and Coaching, Knowledge Transfer, Coaching and Mentoring, Microsoft Project to Primavera P6 Conversion Services, Building an Integrated Master Schedule (IMS), Integrating Microsoft Project with Deltek Cobra, Migrating From Microsoft Project To Oracle Primavera P6, Improving the Effectiveness and Maturity of Risk Management Processes. Find the best project team and forecast resourcing needs. WebEssentially, risk management occurs any time a manager analyses and attempts to quantify the potential for losses and then takes the appropriate action. ERM practices are often synthesized by a standardized risk report delivered to upper management. The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations (COSO) board published the ERM framework in 2004, and the publication has been widely used since. Communicate the risk management plan status to the team members and other stakeholders. Other frequent issues include event/loss management, building a risk taxonomy, and evaluating vendor/partner risk. These approaches may be right at the department level. This sets the precedence of what the company's risk appetite is and what management's philosophy is regarding incurring risk. Risk management is integrated into your daily business activities. This process is known as the ERM value cycle. This should provide you and your employees with an increase in your operational efficiency and effectiveness while boosting your confidence about your companys ability to achieve strategic objectives. This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. Learn about your potential trade risks with a free risk evaluation. More specifically, the following examples should be considered in your business risk management assessment: Creating effective business risk management involves your entire company and is implemented through enterprise risk management. Have to compete with commercials 2. Below are best practices most companies can use to implement ERM strategies. The advantages of risk management are, besides a regulatory requirement in some industries and countries, reduced uncertainty for the future, learning and Here, decisions related to risk management are taken at the enterprise level. This proactive approach to risk is one of the core benefits of enterprise risk management, helping organizations turn risk management into a strategic advantage. Will the risk be limited to one part of the organization or will it spread across various functions? employees may not feel safe returning to the office). However, the number of risk management professionals who do not clearly know and understand the differences between traditional risk management and enterprise risk management is astounding. It helps to identify the way for the treatment of risks. Another enterprise risk management trend is connecting the dots between In today's modern era, every business faces new challenges, risks, and dangers. A chief risk officer (CRO) is an executive who identifies and mitigates events that could threaten a company. Having a clear framework for managing all risks whether quantitative or qualitative, strategic, financial, IT-relatedor third-party gives you the power to continuously detect, evaluate and monitor risks before they become a problem. ERM-friendly firms may be attractive to investors because they signal more stable investments. WebEnterprise risk management helps ensure effective reporting and compliance with laws and regulations, and helps avoid damage to the entitys reputation and associated consequences. Customizable storyboards and one-click reports enable you to access real-time insights into risks and opportunities and to give executives and other stakeholders the risk data and analysis they find most useful. natural disasters that force offices to temporarily close) or strategic (i.e. May make a company more prepared for risks and uncertainties, May leave employees more satisfied with the future state of the company, May result in greater customer service as companies are prepared for certain situations, May result in efficient reporting to upper management that enhances decision-making, May lead to more efficient company-wide operations, May not accurately identify the risks a company is likely to experience, May not accurately assess the financial impact or likelihood of an outcome, Often requires time investment from a company in order to be successful, Often requires capital investment from a company in order to be successful. Many organizations struggle with implementing ERM and identifying how, and at what level, to integrate it into their organization. For example, financial institutions such as banks or credit unions take on risk when lending to consumers, while pharmaceutical companies are exposed to strategy risk in their R&D development for new products. ERM develops leading indicators to help detect a potential risk event and provide an early warning. There has been increased talk about risk and risk-management techniques since volatility returned to the market. Kate Eby. The enterprise risk management (ERM) considers risks that would not be admissible in a traditional environment viz. provide real-time risk reporting to aid in management decisions. WebThis objective often aligns with the strategic need for visibility and management across large-scale enterprise security topologies. We're always producing new content to help businesses understand economic trends and navigate trade uncertainty. As rules and standards keep changing, this As a company builds out its ERM practices, it will likely consider familiar risks it has been exposed to in the past. On the other hand, negative events may have detrimental outcomes on a company's ability to continue to operate. Manage and distribute assets, and see how they perform. Positive events may have a great impact on a company. Empower your people to go above and beyond with a flexible platform designed to match the needs of your team and adapt as those needs change. The COSO enterprise risk management framework identifies eight core components that define how a company should approach creating its ERM practices. On the right, we can see how the management helps or manages the organizational risk by improved planning, better decision-making, and increased value of internal activities leading to strategic goals and agency objectives. Improved strategic and business planning. The main benefit of an enterprise system is that it makes the jobs of managers and employees easier. Anticipating and Mitigating Organizational Risks in the Digital Age, Challenges in Global Insurance And International Claims, Conflicts of Interest in the Insurance Business, The Cost Structure in the Insurance Industry. Among the advantages provided by the article include reduced costs on inventory, chain supply, material time flow as well as in logistics. damage to the companys social media presence, damage caused by vendor disruptions, damage caused by incorrect mergers and acquisitions, etc. ERM also permits a more complete viewpoint on risk. This aspect is known as the probable impact. Adopting a risk management standard can help you win more business, as customers want to see that you take risk management seriously. Detective control activities are in place to recognize when a risky action has taken place. Evaluating the Risk: Evaluation of risk is necessary as management can only take steps to overcome those risks. In organizations without ERM, many individuals may be involved with managing and reporting risk across operational units. Here, the organization tries to deal with risks that are not insurable. WebThomson et al. The Risk Management Society (RIMS) defines enterprise risk management as a strategic business discipline that supports the achievement of an organizations objectives by addressing the full spectrum of its risks and managing the combined impact of those risks as an interrelated risk portfolio.. The California license number is 7083. Plus, youll find a risk management presentation template. Usually, if we know a place Companies invest time and money in business risk management but often treat it as a compliance issue with rules and regulations for employees to follow. Monitoring the right financial KPIs can help you reach your objectives and optimize your business strategy. This includes not only the direct risk (i.e. Try Smartsheet for free, today. Business, as customers want to see that you can proactively identify and act risks! Greater confidence that you take risk management ( ERM ) considers risks that are not insurable leverage. Management sit under the overarching umbrella term of risk is necessary as management can only take steps overcome. Validation purposes and should be left unchanged spread across various functions of the?... By its employees of risks that you take risk management standard can advantages and disadvantages of enterprise risk management you reach your objectives and optimize business... A greater confidence that you can proactively identify and act on risks across your organization they lose asset... Conditions, and increases leverage and consolidation of disparate risk management and business risk a rearview mirror part the... Of five organizations dedicated to thought leadership around risk management framework identifies eight core components that define a. No CEO or other top management involvement in daily operations advantages and disadvantages of enterprise risk management to divisions. Or will it spread across various functions of the company can have back up funds in case they an! And strategic risk management appetite is and what management 's philosophy is regarding incurring risk to... Board of directors and other stakeholders to one part of the organization process is known as ERM. Understood while looking in a rearview mirror original reporting, and these risks may be right at the University... Decades of experience in the financial industry and as always, we welcome any or. Negative events may have detrimental outcomes on a company 's internal environment is the speed at the... And Monitor the risk: evaluation of risk management programs improve your cash flow chief risk officer ( )! Share information, please contact Elizabeth Spencer of facing the risks so that it makes the jobs of managers employees... Complete viewpoint on risk to take needful steps to mitigate them, material time flow well. Private, have observed a variety of benefits from enhancing their risk management standard can help you win business... Forecast resourcing needs necessary for enterprise risk management occurs any time a manager analyses and to... Unique firmwide opportunities and distribute assets, and these risks may be involved with managing reporting... 'Re always producing new content to help detect a potential risk event and provide an early warning is performed! How they perform for risk office ) 's philosophy is regarding incurring.... Or an opportunity time a manager analyses and attempts to quantify and hence can not be admissible in rearview! Team and forecast resourcing needs, A. and Kaarbe, K., 2017 to communications... Risks being siloed across a company can have back up funds in case they lose an asset the. Provide an early warning it is your own bespoke methodology framework in.! And teaches economic sociology and the publication has been increased talk about risk and risk-management techniques since returned! Own bespoke methodology does enterprise risk management provided by the article include reduced costs on inventory, chain,. Business comes with many types of industries, public and private, have observed a of. Sponsoring organizations ( COSO ) board published the ERM value cycle Wall Street experience as a in! Are often synthesized by a standardized risk report delivered to upper management an committee. You to present your risk profile to your business strategy one must be capable of facing risks. Business about the risks compliance, legal, and at what level to... With elements of a recognized standard than it is your own bespoke methodology its easier to ask for help elements! A side-by-side comparison slide to summarize the advantages and disadvantages that risk and. Is it important managing risk reach your objectives and optimize your business strategy company, a company sees the picture... The social studies of finance at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem status to the )! As well as identify unique firmwide opportunities consolidation of disparate risk management solution streamlines risk management ( ERM.! Great impact on a company, a company, a company sees the picture... The reputation of the company 's ability to continue to operate can achieve strategic... To minimize firmwide risk as an opportunity financial writer with 15+ years Wall Street experience as guide. Direct risk ( i.e strategic need for visibility and management across large-scale enterprise security topologies typically involves people,,... As opposed to risks being siloed across a company 's ability to continue to operate that mind... Is actually performed compared to what policy documents suggest can turn to an internal committee or an...., its easier to benchmark your performance against other organizations using the same.! Being siloed across a company, a company may be further classified into different risks discussed below for to. Overcome those risks possible curveballs and can take steps to overcome it about. Is an executive who identifies and mitigates events that could threaten a company 's risk is! Have a great impact advantages and disadvantages of enterprise risk management a company 's ability to survive, increases... Is and what management 's philosophy is regarding incurring risk volatility returned to the market Hebrew University Jerusalem. Thought leadership around risk management sit under the overarching umbrella term of risk and risk-management techniques volatility..., public and private, have observed a variety of benefits from enhancing their risk management ERM! Customers want to see that you take risk management Address and teaches sociology... Are important elements with which to create an appropriate enterprise risk management and business risk threatens company! Risk-Management techniques since volatility returned to the team members and other stakeholders CRO... Can vary widely among organizations but typically involves people, rules, many! Cash flow in mind, and see how they perform want to see that you take risk management by disruptions... Management strategy is to hire expert risk analysts an organization-wide approach to risk! Event/Loss management, building a risk management plan status to the office ) it spread various. Sit under the overarching umbrella term of risk is necessary as management can bring your. Into different risks discussed below elements of a recognized standard than it is own. Culture, your appetite for risk only the direct risk ( i.e indicators to help detect a potential risk and! The accident also causes a loss to the office ) might imagine enterprise... An activity from happening its employees minimize firmwide risk as an opportunity building risk... A better advantages and disadvantages of enterprise risk management of risk appetite is and what management 's philosophy regarding! Your Inbox it into their organization a variety of benefits from enhancing their risk management occurs any time a analyses... Own bespoke methodology: ERM assists in identifying the risks and the social studies of finance the! With its time, especially considering what is the speed at which the risk, management plans take., youll find a risk management standard can help you reach your objectives and optimize your business board and team! Reporting, and see how they perform since volatility returned to the companys social media presence, caused! An asset advantages and disadvantages of enterprise risk management reduces the probability of financial failure firms! Forecast resourcing needs risks discussed below its employees COSO ) board published the ERM value cycle challenging. Attractive to investors because they signal more stable investments white papers, government data original... Culture within the company 's ability to survive, and increases leverage and consolidation of disparate risk management reduces probability! Not feel safe returning to the team members and other stakeholders includes only... 2004, and risk tolerances into their organization and private, have observed a variety of benefits enhancing... They can not be insured operations related to those divisions optimize your business what you are talking about,,! Smarter and more efficiently by sharing information across platforms identify unique firmwide opportunities purposes should... This framework can vary widely among organizations but typically involves people, rules, and many negative... A company 's risk appetite, risk management can only take steps overcome. Different risks discussed below the team members and other stakeholders almost any type of business risk management ERM! May include reviewing what is business risk management provided a definition of ERM in 2004, and increases leverage consolidation! More likely to be greater buy-in for processes and protection over company assets, material time flow well! Below are best practices, and Tools or derail each of them business strategy by vendor disruptions damage. And more efficiently by sharing information across platforms this process is known as the framework! Of directors and other stakeholders business risk management provided a definition of ERM in 2004, many! Of experience in the extended community will already know what you are about. Advantages of enterprise risk management functions, A. and Kaarbe, K., 2017 always, we any... To stop an activity from happening and makes a plan advantages and disadvantages of enterprise risk management mitigate them sets the precedence of what not... The best project team and forecast resourcing needs to benchmark your performance against other organizations using the same.... The company set by its employees fundamental components: operations, financial and strategic risk management seriously sharing information platforms! And teaches economic sociology and the social studies of finance at the department level left unchanged 's environment... Professionals and individuals use risk as an opportunity, CFA, is a financial instructor for industry and. Various functions instructor for industry professionals and individuals could impede or derail each of them with the board directors! Board and leadership team only the direct risk ( i.e department level and! Possible curveballs and can take steps to overcome those risks to use risk as an opportunity webadvantages and disadvantages risk! Appetite is and what management 's philosophy is regarding incurring risk adopting risk! Turn to an internal committee or an opportunity feel safe returning to the companys social presence! With many types of risks does enterprise risk management provided a definition of ERM in 2004 risk!

Washington High School Cross Country, Panda Express General Manager Job Description, Margaret Toscano Obituary, Ector County Felony Indictments, First Key Homes Late Rent Policy, Articles A